Sean Fear: “What’s happened to the Tory right?”
Why aren’t they in open revolt?
There is a widespread view that the Right of the Conservative Party loathe the Coalition with the Liberal Democrats, after the Conservativesâ€™ failure to win an overall majority on May 6th, and will be looking to break up the Coalition as soon as they can.
Certainly, Right wing Conservatives have gained fewer ministerial posts than they could have expected, had the Party won enough seats to govern on its own. Likewise, cherished policies such as seeking the return of powers from the EU, replacing the Human Rights Act, tax breaks for married couples, and slashing inheritance tax have either been shelved, or put on the back burner. Commentators like Simon Heffer, Peter Hitchens, and Melanie Philips never lose an opportunity to castigate the Conservatives and accuse them of betrayal.
But the vast majority of Tory supporters are happy. The latest Yougov survey, 85% of Conservative voters approve the Coalitionâ€™s record to date, while 4% oppose it; an extraordinary 98% of Conservatives approve of Cameronâ€™s record as Prime Minister, while 1% disapprove.
Of course, Conservative voters are not necessarily the same people as Conservative members, and not all Conservative voters are on the Right of the Party. That said, it is most unlikely that Right wing Conservativesâ€™ attitudes are all that different from Conservative voters as a whole. Even if, say, â€œonlyâ€ 70% of Right wing Conservatives support the Coalition, thatâ€™s a very high measure of support.
So, why arenâ€™t the Right unhappy with the Coalition?
Firstly, there comes a point when one gets sick of losing. Purity of principle is all well and good, but when one gets repeatedly defeated, its charms begin to fade. In the early years of Opposition, itâ€™s easy enough to refuse to compromise. As time goes on, one starts to appreciate that 50% of something is preferable to 100% of nothing.
Secondly, the economic crisis has concentrated minds. I, and Iâ€™m sure plenty of other Right wing Conservatives, were impressed by the violence in Greece, in the run up to the general election. It occurred to me that even if the Conservatives were to win a small overall majority, it would be hugely difficult to push through the necessary cuts in public spending, without very broad political backing. The fact that the Coalition has the backing of parties that won 61% of the vote between them, makes it far easier for the government to cut, than if it had won a bare majority of the seats on 37% of the vote. I doubt if I am the only Right wing Conservative who is thinking along these lines.
Finally, viewed objectively, this is shaping up to be a remarkably radical government. In the post-war period, itâ€™s hard to think of any government, in any Western country, that has been so determined to shrink the State, except possibly the Labour government in New Zealand that was dominated by Roger Douglas.
When Nick Clegg said that the cuts wouldnâ€™t be like those imposed by Margaret Thatcher, he was correct; Margaret Thatcher would never have dared to introduce the sort of cuts that George Osborne intends to make. If the Coalition is successful, then post-War social democracy will cease to be a viable political philosophy in this country.
What Right wing Conservative could be unhappy about that?